{
 "name": "Catheter Robot Atlas",
 "generated": "2026-11-11",
 "schema": "sim2real.schema.json",
 "metadata_licence": "to be decided by the maintainers (CC0-1.0 or CC-BY-4.0)",
 "pictures": "Each picture keeps its owner's licence (see picture.licence); only cleared pictures are published.",
 "count": 26,
 "studies": [
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "behr2019_deep",
   "year": 2019,
   "venue": "Curr. Dir. Biomed. Eng. 5(1)",
   "title": "Deep Reinforcement Learning for the Navigation of Neurovascular Catheters",
   "doi": "10.1515/cdbme-2019-0002",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "fraunhofer_karstensen2022",
   "robot_used": "Fraunhofer IPA experimental robotic manipulator for the two DOF of a guidewire: maximum linear travel 300 mm, infinite rotation (Sec. 2.4); guidewire only, no catheter; overhead camera, MeVisLab tracking (Sec. 2.3)",
   "simulator": "SOFA + BeamAdapter; rigid vessel walls, wall-guidewire friction 0.1, empty lumen (no dynamic resistance) (Sec. 2.2)",
   "trained": "policy (DDPG, with HER and human demonstrations as options, OpenAI Baselines; DQN with double Q-learning, dueling networks, prioritised replay, RLlib) (Sec. 2.1); only DDPG ran on the test bench (Sec. 2.5)",
   "observation": "absolute guidewire tip coordinates, the target and the manipulator rotation (Sec. 2.1); on the bench, tip from an overhead camera registered to a CT of the phantom, threshold segmentation and centreline (Sec. 2.3)",
   "action_space": "DDPG: continuous translation and rotation; DQN: discrete, 8 combinations of the two DOF (Sec. 2.1)",
   "gap_closing": "none described; 'The simulation does not yet include noise and latency' (Sec. 3)",
   "real_setup": "idealised PMMA phantom, constant 10 mm vessel diameter, a bifurcation followed by a bi- and trifurcation in one plane, water-filled; random start and target; 10 bench runs (Sec. 2.4, 3, Fig. 3)",
   "sim_success": "DDPG + HER 89.6% (sparse reward), DQN + Rainbow 86.5% (dense reward), average success rates; SD over four training attempts 4.4% and 6.2%; plain DDPG 83.1%, DDPG + HER + HD 87.9% (Sec. 3, Figs. 4-5); episodes per evaluation N.R.",
   "real_success": "7/10 (the trained DDPG model on the test bench) (Sec. 3)",
   "gap_measure": "89.6% -> 70% (7/10), reading the transferred 'trained DDPG model' as the DDPG + HER of the same paragraph; failed attempts 'happened at junctions, where exact state data is necessary' (Sec. 3)",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Primary read 2026-11-08: not simulation-only. The two reviews did not disagree: Robertshaw 2023 (70% DDPG) gives the bench result and Sun 2025 (86.5% DQN / 89.6% DDPG) the simulated one. Same 2-DOF manipulator, camera tracking and simulation framework that karstensen2020_autonomous 'reused'. Planar idealised phantom, guidewire only."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "you2019_automatic",
   "year": 2019,
   "venue": "J. Mech. Sci. Technol. 33(11)",
   "title": "Automatic control of cardiac ablation catheter with deep reinforcement learning method",
   "doi": "10.1007/s12206-019-1036-0",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": null,
   "robot_used": "tendon-driven steerable EP-catheter robot, 3 motors (translation, rotation, distal bending); TactiCath Quartz catheter; Aurora EM tracker (Fig. 1)",
   "simulator": "Unity (catheter + heart collision model; rendered to angiography-like images)",
   "trained": "policy (dueling DQN)",
   "observation": "two 256x256 simulated angiography images (previous + current step) plus tip and goal positions; on hardware tip from EM, image rendered from EM positions",
   "action_space": "discrete, 8 actions (translate 1 mm, rotate 3 deg, bend 1 deg)",
   "gap_closing": "randomised insertion angle and action magnitude (two noise types)",
   "real_setup": "printed rigid right-atrium phantom, 100 episodes per model",
   "sim_success": "98%, 96%, 97%, 96% (four models)",
   "real_success": "73% (no randomisation); 78%, 75% (one noise type); 87% (both)",
   "gap_measure": "success 98% -> 73% without randomisation; 96% -> 87% with both noise types (S7b Table S7b2; paper Table 2)",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Intracardiac, tendon-driven catheter, not a neurovascular guidewire robot. Earliest simulation-to-robot study in the S7b set that measures a gap with and without randomisation."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "karstensen2020_autonomous",
   "year": 2020,
   "venue": "Curr. Dir. Biomed. Eng. 6(1), 20200007",
   "title": "Autonomous guidewire navigation in a two dimensional vascular phantom",
   "doi": "10.1515/cdbme-2020-0007",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "fraunhofer_karstensen2022",
   "robot_used": "Fraunhofer IPA guidewire manipulator, 2 DOF (translation, rotation), 'reused' from behr2019_deep; gamepad for manual override; camera above and light source below the phantom emulating fluoroscopy, 5 Hz (Materials and methods, Fig. 1)",
   "simulator": "SOFA + BeamAdapter; phantom walls rigid, lumen empty; wall friction and guidewire stiffness iteratively tuned to mimic guidewire failure in the test bench (Materials and methods)",
   "trained": "policy (DDPG + HER)",
   "observation": "five guidewire points 5 mm apart from the tip (XZ) for the current and last three time steps, plus the last three actions (Materials and methods); on the bench from the camera image at 5 Hz; target coordinates given to the network (interim-target test)",
   "action_space": "continuous translation and rotation commands; control at 5 Hz",
   "gap_closing": "friction and guidewire stiffness tuned to reproduce the bench failure (entanglement at bifurcations); on the bench, the next bifurcation given as interim target",
   "real_setup": "rigid 2D phantom, stereolithography print, filled with glycerine-water; a loop that forces a detour and a bifurcation that needs translation and rotation together (Fig. 2); random start and target; number of bench episodes N.R.",
   "sim_success": "maximum 96% after 52,500 training episodes (100 test episodes every 500 training episodes; success = target within 25 s) (Materials and methods, Results, Fig. 3)",
   "real_success": "'the same results as navigating in the simulation environment' (no number, episodes N.R.); 100% with the next bifurcation as interim target, evaluated 'to improve the success rate on the testbench' (Materials and methods, Results)",
   "gap_measure": "none stated: bench reported equal to simulation without a count; failures of the fully trained controller are path-choice (high-level) failures only (Results)",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Second Fraunhofer bench study: same manipulator, camera tracking and simulation framework as behr2019_deep. First statement of the friction-and-stiffness tuning procedure later quoted from karstensen2022_learning. The bench success is a verbal statement, so fig_sim2real (b) draws no line for it."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "cho2022_sim",
   "year": 2022,
   "venue": "IROS",
   "title": "Sim-to-Real Transfer of Image-Based Autonomous Guidewire Navigation Trained by Deep Deterministic Policy Gradient with Behavior Cloning for Fast Learning",
   "doi": "10.1109/iros47612.2022.9982168",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "kaist_cho2022",
   "robot_used": "bench guidewire controller (translation + rotation) under overhead camera (Fig. 8); no robot name",
   "simulator": "SOFA (virtual planar vessel map)",
   "trained": "policy (DDPG after behaviour cloning from a rule-based expert)",
   "observation": "four stacked 128x128 3-channel images centred on tip (vessel mask, centreline, guidewire centreline) plus 4 previous actions; same hand-written image processing in both domains",
   "action_space": "continuous: translate up to 0.8 mm, rotate up to 30 deg per step",
   "gap_closing": "image reduced to masks in both domains; image rotation, shift 0.2, scale 0.7-1 augmentation",
   "real_setup": "planar phantom of a different shape, camera 30 Hz, 4 targets x 10 episodes",
   "sim_success": "100/100, 41.08 s (expert 66.17 s)",
   "real_success": "40/40, 35.06 s (expert 63.2 s)",
   "gap_measure": "none (same or better; real vessel differs from sim vessel)",
   "code_public": "no (video only)",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Easiest transfer in the set: 2D planar map, image abstracted to masks, camera pose fixed. Real-vessel shape differs from training map, so it also tests geometry generalisation."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "dreyfus2022_simulation",
   "year": 2022,
   "venue": "IEEE Robot. Autom. Lett. 7(3)",
   "title": "A Simulation Framework for Magnetic Continuum Robots",
   "doi": "10.1109/lra.2022.3187249",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": null,
   "robot_used": "magnetic continuum robot, 1.5 mm (4.5 Fr) OD, three NdFeB ring magnets, pushed by a remote-controlled advancer and steered by a pre-clinical eMNS of 3 coils on a triangular base, up to 25 mT (Sec. III-A, III-B, Fig. 3)",
   "simulator": "SOFA + BeamAdapter (1D Kirchhoff-rod FEM, Lagrange-multiplier contact, Coulomb friction 0.01 in validation, Sec. III-E) coupled through ROS to a multipole model of the eMNS field, b(p) = A(p) i; advancer enters as the user insertion speed (Sec. II-A, II-B, Fig. 4)",
   "trained": "None",
   "observation": "Tip position and pointing angle (camera markers on the bench; simulated tip in SOFA)",
   "action_space": "Recorded field and advancer inputs of a user, replayed open loop",
   "gap_closing": "Young's moduli swept by hand in an obstacle-free calibration model; friction tuned by hand (Sec. III-F, V)",
   "real_setup": "planar, 4 mm high, rigid POM and PMMA models (calibration, vasculature-like, free-form); Canon EOS 6D camera (Sec. III-C, III-D)",
   "sim_success": "n/a",
   "real_success": "mean tip position error 5.1 to 6.8 mm and orientation error 3.8 to 7.2 deg over the three models (phantom); per-way-point errors in Table II",
   "gap_measure": "tip position and orientation error between real and simulated device over the whole navigation (Sec. III-G, V)",
   "code_public": "yes (github.com/ethz-msrl/mCR_simulator, release v1.0.0)",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Simulated vs physical device without a controller: belongs in Table VIII(c). Models the field source of a magnetic device but not the advancer (no slip); rigid vessels, no blood flow, no image rendering (RViz only). eMNS not named in the paper; no catalogue row attached."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "karstensen2022_learning",
   "year": 2022,
   "venue": "IJCARS 17(11)",
   "title": "Learning-based autonomous vascular guidewire navigation without human demonstration in the venous system of a porcine liver",
   "doi": "10.1007/s11548-022-02646-8",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "fraunhofer_karstensen2022",
   "robot_used": "customised guidewire manipulator (continuous rotation; translation up to 300 mm) under C-arm fluoroscopy",
   "simulator": "SOFA + BeamAdapter (rigid wall, empty lumen; 0.035 in Terumo Radifocus angled stiff guidewire)",
   "trained": "policy (deep RL, controller with recurrent layers; algorithm not re-checked); perception was a separate recurrent-CNN tracker",
   "observation": "5 tip points 1 mm apart in 2D; on hardware from real 7.5 fps fluoroscopy through recurrent-CNN tracker (error ~1.3 mm); tracking delay modelled as normal, mean 0.13 s",
   "action_space": "continuous translation + rotation of the wire base",
   "gap_closing": "friction and wire stiffness hand-tuned to mimic the test bench; tracking delay in training",
   "real_setup": "ex vivo porcine liver (one organ; CT mesh from the same liver) with pump flow; 10 targets per main vein",
   "sim_success": "150/150 (100%) at training end",
   "real_success": "9/30 (30%): wrong branch 10, entanglement 11",
   "gap_measure": "-70 points; failure split wrong branch 33.3%, entanglement 36.6% (Table 1); authors blame soft-tissue registration for wrong-branch failures",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "First learned controller in S7b run under real fluoroscopy. Largest measured drop. Rigid wall in sim vs compliant liver vessels in reality is the unmodelled difference."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "zhang2022_robotic",
   "year": 2022,
   "venue": "IROS 2022",
   "title": "Robotic Actuation and Control of a Catheter for Structural Intervention Cardiology",
   "doi": "10.1109/iros47612.2022.9981676",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "polimi_zhang2022",
   "robot_used": "PoliMi motorised stabiliser for the 16 Fr MitraClip delivery catheter",
   "simulator": "Unity scene of the CT-reconstructed heart; Cosserat-rod kinematic model of the catheter",
   "trained": "policy (BC + GAIL path planner)",
   "observation": "planner in simulation; hardware: EM sensor with PID loop",
   "action_space": "",
   "gap_closing": "",
   "real_setup": "patient-specific silicone phantom",
   "sim_success": "N.R.",
   "real_success": "N.R. (position error 1.12 / 1.09 / 1.66 mm X/Y/Z, max 2.64 mm)",
   "gap_measure": "no success rate",
   "code_public": "",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Structural heart (transseptal mitral edge-to-edge repair). Source: A9_west_gaps.md, polimi_zhang2022 (zhang2022 Sec. IV-V, full text). Moved from figures/src/sim2real_extra.py on 2026-10-14 (F5)."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "jianu2024_cathsim",
   "year": 2024,
   "venue": "IEEE T-MRB 6(3)",
   "title": "CathSim: An Open-Source Simulator for Endovascular Intervention",
   "doi": "10.1109/tmrb.2024.3421256",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "cathbot_kundrat2021",
   "robot_used": "CathBot follower (real data from Kundrat et al., ATI Mini40 force on Type-I silicone arch)",
   "simulator": "CathSim (MuJoCo; rigid-link catheter chain, rigid wall)",
   "trained": "none for this comparison (RL baselines elsewhere in paper)",
   "observation": "simulated contact force",
   "action_space": "joint-level (20 tip motors + translation)",
   "gap_closing": "force-distribution comparison only",
   "real_setup": "silicone Type-I arch phantom, CathBot force experiment",
   "sim_success": "n/a",
   "real_success": "n/a",
   "gap_measure": "force distributions not significantly different (Mann-Whitney p ~ 0.445, S7a)",
   "code_public": "yes (github.com/airvlab/cathsim)",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Simulation-vs-real measurement, no policy transfer. The simulated robot is the follower with joints actuated directly: no drive model."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "scarponi2024_fbg",
   "year": 2024,
   "venue": "Healthc. Technol. Lett. 11(6)",
   "title": "FBG-driven simulation for virtual augmentation of fluoroscopic images during endovascular interventions",
   "doi": "10.1049/htl2.12108",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": null,
   "robot_used": "N.R. (user study with FBG-guided catheter on rigid 3D-printed aorta)",
   "simulator": "SOFA (Timoshenko beam, catheter + wire overlap)",
   "trained": "none (FBG shape pulls simulation, gain 0.8)",
   "observation": "FBG shape",
   "action_space": "n/a",
   "gap_closing": "moduli fitted by bending test; online shape correction",
   "real_setup": "rigid aorta phantom, 8 locations",
   "sim_success": "n/a",
   "real_success": "n/a",
   "gap_measure": "simulated vs real shape 2.0 +/- 0.9 mm; predicted catheter after wire withdrawal 2.4 +/- 1.3 mm (right 1.3, left 3.5)",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "partial",
   "notes": "Real2sim shape feedback; closest published precedent for continuous twin updating."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "wen2024_guidewire_seg",
   "year": 2024,
   "venue": "arXiv:2410.07460",
   "title": null,
   "doi": null,
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": null,
   "robot_used": "none (perception only)",
   "simulator": "synthetic fluoroscopy from simulation",
   "trained": "perception (SAM adapted, style transfer + self-training)",
   "observation": "X-ray fluoroscopy guidewire mask",
   "action_space": "n/a",
   "gap_closing": "style-transfer pseudo-labels, teacher-student consistency; no target labels",
   "real_setup": "public cardiac dataset + in-house neurovascular dataset",
   "sim_success": "n/a",
   "real_success": "N.R. here",
   "gap_measure": "N.R. (abstract only)",
   "code_public": "announced",
   "read_level": "abstract",
   "notes": "Only perception-side sim-to-real paper found for guidewires."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "karstensen2025_learning",
   "year": 2025,
   "venue": "Comput. Biol. Med. 196 (arXiv:2410.01956)",
   "title": "Learning-based autonomous navigation, benchmark environments and simulation framework for endovascular interventions",
   "doi": "10.1016/j.compbiomed.2025.110844",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "fraunhofer_karstensen2022",
   "robot_used": "custom guidewire manipulator: stepper rotating the wire directly (infinite rotation) on a linear rail driven by a second stepper (300 mm); housing labelled \"guido\" in Fig. 4",
   "simulator": "stEVE / SOFA BeamAdapter; stEVE_bench BasicWireNav, ArchVariety, DualDeviceNav",
   "trained": "policy (SAC + LSTM)",
   "observation": "3 tip points in 2D, current + previous, target, last action; hardware: overhead-camera tracker (transparent phantom) or fluoroscopy tracker",
   "action_space": "continuous translation (35 mm/s) and rotation (3.14 rad/s) per device, 7.5 Hz",
   "gap_closing": "hand-tuned friction and stiffness (Karstensen 2022 procedure); ArchVariety randomises arch shape and scale 0.7-1.3",
   "real_setup": "3D-printed rigid aortic arch phantoms; camera bench 100+100 trials, fluoroscopy 10 trials",
   "sim_success": "BasicWireNav 98/100; ArchVariety 90/100; DualDeviceNav 40/100 (sim only)",
   "real_success": "BasicWireNav camera 97/100 (9/10 on the first 10), fluoroscopy 10/10; ArchVariety camera 84/100",
   "gap_measure": "-1 and -6 points; duration 9.6 s -> 13.6 s (p = 0.011); path ratio of failures 94.3% -> 81.6% (p = 0.045); sim-vs-camera success p = 0.653 and 0.209",
   "code_public": "yes: github.com/lkarstensen/stEVE, stEVE_bench, stEVE_training",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Smallest gap in the set, on a rigid phantom with one wire and tracked-tip observation. Fig. 4 left = camera bench, right = fluoroscopy bench; simulation views are Fig. 2 and Fig. 5 (not cropped)."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "luo2025_rlmg",
   "year": 2025,
   "venue": "RCAR 2025",
   "title": "RL-MG: Reinforcement Learning Framework for Magnetic Guidewire Path Following",
   "doi": "10.1109/rcar65431.2025.11139440",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "siatguidewire_zhang2022",
   "robot_used": "SIAT magnetic guidewire system: UR5 + 60 x 60 mm permanent magnet + guidewire advancer",
   "simulator": "SOFA + BeamAdapter (Kirchhoff rod), dipole field from COMSOL; SolidWorks vessel models",
   "trained": "policy (DDPG, 400 episodes)",
   "observation": "state vector: magnet pose, guidewire tip, reference path points; hardware: depth camera + YOLOv11",
   "action_space": "",
   "gap_closing": "",
   "real_setup": "femoral-artery model, 4 paths x 3 trials",
   "sim_success": "N.R. (error 2.5/3.1/2.2/2.4 mm, time 7.0/13.0/12.0/9.0 s)",
   "real_success": "N.R. (error 3.6/3.8/3.1/2.8 mm, time 31.0/64.0/45.0/67.0 s)",
   "gap_measure": "no success rate; error 2.2-3.1 -> 2.8-3.8 mm, time 7-13 -> 31-67 s",
   "code_public": "",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Magnetic guidewire; actions = magnet translation and rotation + guidewire advancement. Source: W5_notes.md finding 1 (luo2025_rlmg, full text, Table I). Moved from figures/src/sim2real_extra.py on 2026-10-14 (F5)."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "mei2025_freezeseg2rl",
   "year": 2025,
   "venue": "PRICAI 2025 (Springer LNCS, print 2026)",
   "title": "FreezeSeg2RL: Frozen Segmentation Pretraining for Reinforcement Learning On Vascular Interventional Robot Autonomous Delivering",
   "doi": "10.1007/978-981-95-7072-0_25",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "xmu_mei2025",
   "robot_used": "vascular interventional robot with X-ray, ex-vivo platform in an operating room, agent on a laptop (RTX 3060) outside; robot not described",
   "simulator": "pymunk 2D X-ray simulation platform (same group as EVEGARS); ARCADE tasks + 4 in-vitro-model tasks",
   "trained": "perception (frozen DeepLabV3+ segmentation encoder pretrained on 5,138 simulated images) + policy (actor-critic RL)",
   "observation": "real X-ray image from the operating room, cropped, aligned, target boxed",
   "action_space": "5 discrete: advance 10 mm, retract 10 mm, rotate 90 deg cw, rotate 90 deg ccw, wait 1 s",
   "gap_closing": "data augmentation (named as crucial for sim-to-real); frozen pretrained encoder",
   "real_setup": "4 delivery tasks, 120 s limit, trials per task N.R.",
   "sim_success": "56.1% ARCADE tasks, 44.8% in-vitro-model tasks (simulated, Table 4)",
   "real_success": "85%, 80%, 80%, 70% (human 100/95/100/95; BC 0%); without data augmentation 25%, 15%, 15%, 5%",
   "gap_measure": "data augmentation removal: -60, -65, -65, -65 points on hardware; sim 44.8% vs hardware 70-85% is not a clean pair (different task sets)",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Same group, same hardware numbers (85/80/80/70, human 100/95/100/95, BC 0) as mei2026_evegars; the \"25/15/15/5\" row is labelled \"w/o DA\" here and \"Ours (25 Tasks)\" there: unresolved which label is right. Treat as one hardware experiment reported twice. Found by A6, not in S7b."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "mei2025_transferring",
   "year": 2025,
   "venue": "IEEE/ASME T-MECH 30(2)",
   "title": "Transferring Virtual Surgical Skills to Reality: AI Agents Mastering Surgical Decision-Making in Vascular Interventional Robotics",
   "doi": "10.1109/tmech.2024.3420954",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "xmu_mei2025",
   "robot_used": "Xiamen guidewire robot: friction-wheel module, rotating platform, microcatheter linear module",
   "simulator": "Pymunk 2D",
   "trained": "policy (multiprocess PPO, three training stages)",
   "observation": "camera image re-rendered to the simulator style",
   "action_space": "",
   "gap_closing": "",
   "real_setup": "transparent vessel model, 4 targets, 40 runs per target",
   "sim_success": "99.30, 99.26 and 98.34 % across three training stages (not the hardware targets)",
   "real_success": "82.5 / 87.5 / 82.5 / 72.5 % (surgeon 100 %, replayed surgeon commands 0 %)",
   "gap_measure": "no matched pair (simulated stages vs hardware targets)",
   "code_public": "",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Same hardware as mei2025_freezeseg2rl and mei2026_evegars. Source: A8_asia_gaps.md, xmu_mei2025 (mei2025_transferring Tables II-III, full text). Moved from figures/src/sim2real_extra.py on 2026-10-14 (F5)."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "pescio2025_simulation",
   "year": 2025,
   "venue": "IJCARS",
   "title": "A simulation environment for robot-assisted endovascular interventions",
   "doi": "10.1007/s11548-025-03458-2",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "cathbot_kundrat2021",
   "robot_used": "CathBot drives a peripheral catheter into silicone abdominal-aorta phantom (13 and 23 mm/s)",
   "simulator": "SOFA + BeamAdapter; Signorini contact with Coulomb friction 0.62; vessel FE",
   "trained": "none",
   "observation": "tip position, contact force (ATI Mini40)",
   "action_space": "imposed insertion displacement",
   "gap_closing": "friction coefficient and catheter parameters selected among nine settings",
   "real_setup": "silicone aorta phantom with fiducials, bead registration",
   "sim_success": "n/a",
   "real_success": "n/a",
   "gap_measure": "contact force absolute error 0.0371 N (30.45%); tip displacement mean error 3.1 mm; Frechet 3.6 mm",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Digital twin of device and vessel; drive modelled as imposed displacement. Measured forces were lower than simulated (a direction-limit device reduced force during pre-bent tip insertion). Second crop pescio2025_simulation_sim.png = simulated catheter model (Fig. 1)."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "yao2025_sim2real",
   "year": 2025,
   "venue": "IEEE T-ASE 22",
   "title": "Sim2Real Learning With Domain Randomization for Autonomous Guidewire Navigation in Robotic-Assisted Endovascular Procedures",
   "doi": "10.1109/tase.2025.3555559",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "unitedimaging_yao2025",
   "robot_used": "vascular intervention robot of United Imaging Research Institute of Intelligent Imaging (Fig. 3, C-arm and table)",
   "simulator": "SOFA 23.06 + BeamAdapter; one 0.9 mm guidewire (density 1.55 g/cm3)",
   "trained": "policy (PPO + GAE + domain randomisation; SAC, DDPG baselines)",
   "observation": "sim: tip position, velocity, curvature, orientation, tip force, vessel diameter; robot: not described (no real-time position feedback needed)",
   "action_space": "insertion, two rotations, torque increment (discrete set)",
   "gap_closing": "domain randomisation: friction uniform [0.1, 0.5] and tissue elasticity [0.5, 2.0] kPa per episode; GAE",
   "real_setup": "simplified vascular phantom with physical twin; 4-5 trials per method; 2 human operators x 3",
   "sim_success": "PPO 7/10 and 8/10; PPO+DR 8/10 and 9/10; PPO+GAE+DR 9/10 and 9/10 (targets A, B)",
   "real_success": "PPO 60% (5 trials); PPO+GAE+DR 100% (5); SAC and DDPG 75% (4); human 100% (3) in 35-39 s",
   "gap_measure": "centreline distance for PPO+GAE+DR: 2.43 +/- 0.37 mm sim vs 2.06 +/- 0.31 mm robot (target B, Table V); no physical result for DR alone; authors: model \"likely failed to fully replicate\" retraction dynamics",
   "code_public": "no (supplement at DOI)",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Only study in the set that randomises friction and wall elasticity. Second crop yao2025_sim2real_sim.png shows the simulated tasks (Fig. 2). Policy runs near open loop."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "yao2025_sim4endor",
   "year": 2025,
   "venue": "ICRA",
   "title": "Sim4EndoR: A Reinforcement Learning Centered Simulation Platform for Task Automation of Endovascular Robotics",
   "doi": "10.1109/icra55743.2025.11127627",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "unitedimaging_yao2025",
   "robot_used": "vascular intervention robot of United Imaging Research Institute of Intelligent Imaging (guidewire insertion + rotation); no spec in the paper",
   "simulator": "Sim4EndoR: SOFA v23.06 + BeamAdapter + Blender; phantom CT-scanned for a matching sim model",
   "trained": "policy (DDPG, PPO, SAC; path-length reward)",
   "observation": "sim: tip position and velocity (ground truth); robot: none described, actions replayed open loop (\"without relying on any real-time position feedback\", Fig. 4 caption)",
   "action_space": "continuous insertion and rotation increments",
   "gap_closing": "\"meticulously calibrating simulation parameters\" (not quantified); no randomisation",
   "real_setup": "coronary phantom, 2 end points, 5 trials each",
   "sim_success": "Task A 5/5, Task B 4/5 (DDPG)",
   "real_success": "Task A 5/5, Task B 3/5",
   "gap_measure": "Task B -1 of 5 (n too small for a statistic); authors name silicone-wall properties and guidewire retraction model as gaps",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Open-loop replay of a simulated action sequence: transfer of a trajectory, not of a closed-loop policy (S7b reading). Crop shows the simulated phantom with start and end points A, B."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "yoo2025_robust",
   "year": 2025,
   "venue": "ICRA",
   "title": "A Robust Deep Reinforcement Learning Framework for Image-Based Autonomous Guidewire Navigation",
   "doi": "10.1109/icra55743.2025.11127741",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "kaist_cho2022",
   "robot_used": "N.R. in the text read (introduction describes master-slave PCI robots generally)",
   "simulator": "SOFA (new random left-coronary tree each training episode)",
   "trained": "policy (PPO with local-map sub-goals along an A* path)",
   "observation": "camera image thresholded to vessel and guidewire maps, skeletons, A* path; 128x128 local map per sub-task plus previous action",
   "action_space": "discrete: translation and rotation each in {-1,0,1} (3 mm, 30 deg)",
   "gap_closing": "randomised vessel trees, action scaling and noise, image deformation and scaling (domain randomisation)",
   "real_setup": "planar phantom, one bench, four paths, 40 runs per test",
   "sim_success": "86.9% (67 episodes x 3) vs 53.7% without vessel randomisation",
   "real_success": "93.3%, 89.2%, 91.7% (three tests); Cho 2022 controller 83.3%, rule-based 19.2% in test I",
   "gap_measure": "none (different path sets; real higher than sim)",
   "code_public": "no (video on YouTube)",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "No clean same-task sim-vs-real pair. Shows that a randomised image pipeline over masks transfers on planar phantoms."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "alabay2026_vista",
   "year": 2026,
   "venue": "arXiv:2608.30220",
   "title": null,
   "doi": null,
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": null,
   "robot_used": "magnetically actuated untethered microrobot (not a catheter robot)",
   "simulator": "3D digital twin of vessels (not a physics policy simulator)",
   "trained": "none (rule-based milestones)",
   "observation": "single-plane fluoroscopy 2D position mapped to centreline milestones",
   "action_space": "magnetic actuation commands",
   "gap_closing": "digital twin gives depth/topology",
   "real_setup": "vascular phantoms with flow + live rat IVC",
   "sim_success": "n/a",
   "real_success": "navigation time -62%, corrective commands -98%, radiation -57% vs human-in-the-loop",
   "gap_measure": "n/a",
   "code_public": "N.R.",
   "read_level": "abstract",
   "notes": "Adjacent; out of the catheter/guidewire scope."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "chen2026_learning",
   "year": 2026,
   "venue": "arXiv:2607.00066 (accepted IROS 2026)",
   "title": "Learning Expert Strategy for Autonomous Robotic Endovascular Intervention via Decoupled Procedural Execution",
   "doi": null,
   "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.00066",
   "robot_id": "allvas_aopeng2021",
   "robot_used": "commercial ALLVAS dual-arm gripper robot with overhead camera (Fig. 4a)",
   "simulator": "Sim4EndoR (SOFA) as digital twin of the phantom",
   "trained": "policy (SAC high-level) + online nonlinear MPC filter (not learned)",
   "observation": "tip pixel position, ResNet-50 image feature, previous action, goal; hardware: overhead camera, YOLOv5 tip detection",
   "action_space": "continuous insertion and rotation speed",
   "gap_closing": "MPC layer enforcing actuator, curvature and wall-clearance constraints; zero-shot deployment",
   "real_setup": "heated silicone phantom with circulation, coronary and transfemoral routes, 20 trials",
   "sim_success": "98%, 96%, 98% (50 episodes per target); SAC alone 92/94/90%",
   "real_success": "18/20 (90.0%), 4.2 +/- 0.8 min per trial",
   "gap_measure": "98.0% -> 90.0%; zero wall-boundary violations reported, detection method not described",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Robot is a clamp-relay (anchor-advance) dual-arm design: sim must model the gripper hand-over, not a roller."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "mei2026_evegars",
   "year": 2026,
   "venue": "PRCV (LNCS)",
   "title": "EVEGARS: End-to-End Vision-Based Endovascular Guidewire Autonomous Reinforcement Learning in Large-Scale Simulations from Clinical Dataset",
   "doi": "10.1007/978-981-95-5740-0_15",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": null,
   "robot_used": "guidewire robot under X-ray with \"ex-vivo model\" and remote station (Fig. 8); robot not described",
   "simulator": "EVEGARS: pymunk 2D rigid-body, 120 ARCADE angiogram masks",
   "trained": "policy (PPO, ResNet-50 + ViT encoder) from images",
   "observation": "X-ray-like image (sim) -> real X-ray image on robot",
   "action_space": "discrete push, pull, rotate, wait; 80 steps",
   "gap_closing": "randomised contrast, brightness, Gaussian noise, path deformation",
   "real_setup": "4 delivery tasks in an undescribed \"ex-vivo model\", trials per task N.R.",
   "sim_success": "91% (denominator N.R.)",
   "real_success": "85%, 80%, 80%, 70% (human 100%, 95%, 100%, 95%; behaviour cloning 0%)",
   "gap_measure": "91% -> 70-85%",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Only image-in policy in the set run on real X-ray. Second crop mei2026_evegars_sim.png = framework figure (simulation side). Ex-vivo claim unverifiable from text."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "robertshaw2026_progressive",
   "year": 2026,
   "venue": "arXiv:2608.18647",
   "title": "Progressive Experience Fusion for Multi-Task World Model Control in Endovascular Navigation",
   "doi": null,
   "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2608.18647",
   "robot_id": "kclneuro_sadati2025",
   "robot_used": "same KCL manipulator, mobile C-arm",
   "simulator": "stEVE / SOFA; 30 training + 10 held-out CTAs",
   "trained": "policy (multi-task, progressive experience fusion), fine-tuned 40k steps in a simulation of the new patient",
   "observation": "2D tip coordinates; no vessel image",
   "action_space": "continuous, two devices",
   "gap_closing": "fine-tuning in a patient-specific simulation before the bench run",
   "real_setup": "unseen printed phantom, 5 runs per sub-task",
   "sim_success": "90% on 10 unseen vasculatures",
   "real_success": "60% without, 67% with fine-tuning (p = 0.623)",
   "gap_measure": "-30 and -23 points; path ratio 63% -> 80% (p < 0.001); authors name stiffer-than-vessel phantom and missing pulsatility",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "partial (abstract, Sec. II-C, III-E, IV)",
   "notes": "Per S7a read level."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "robertshaw2026_safe",
   "year": 2026,
   "venue": "arXiv:2604.20151 (submitted IROS 2026)",
   "title": "Toward Safe Autonomous Robotic Endovascular Interventions using World Models",
   "doi": null,
   "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.20151",
   "robot_id": "kclneuro_sadati2025",
   "robot_used": "same KCL lead-screw manipulator (Fig. 2); max 180 deg/s rotation, 40 mm/s translation; mobile C-arm (Cios Spin)",
   "simulator": "stEVE / SOFA v23.12; 0.0441 in catheter + 0.035 in guidewire; 15 CTAs (5 held out)",
   "trained": "policy (TD-MPC2 world model vs SAC)",
   "observation": "2D tip coordinates from fluoroscopy tracker; no vessel image",
   "action_space": "continuous rotation + translation, two devices",
   "gap_closing": "mesh scale 0.7-1.3, rotation +/-30 deg; tensile test stiffness; friction tuned; 5 min allowed per bench episode",
   "real_setup": "printed phantom of one training vessel under mobile C-arm; 5 runs per task, n = 25",
   "sim_success": "hold-out 58% (n = 250) TD-MPC2 vs 36% SAC",
   "real_success": "68% vs 60% (p = 0.567); left common carotid 0/5 both",
   "gap_measure": "time 17.1 s sim -> 111.0 s bench; augmentation ablation 20% vs 40% (p = 0.549, 5 runs)",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Sim success is on unseen patients, bench on a seen patient: not a matched pair."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "robertshaw2026_towardb",
   "year": 2026,
   "venue": "IEEE RA-L 11(4) (arXiv:2602.18663)",
   "title": "Toward AI Autonomous Navigation for Mechanical Thrombectomy Using Hierarchical Modular Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (HM-MARL)",
   "doi": "10.1109/lra.2026.3664661",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": "kclneuro_sadati2025",
   "robot_used": "KCL lead-screw carriage manipulator: independent actuation carriages (rotation + translation) on a 1 m lead screw, hollow-shaft NEMA 17 steppers, telescopic tubes against lateral buckling; Fig. 3 caption calls it a \"concentric tube robot\" [Sadati 2025]",
   "simulator": "stEVE / SOFA; Navien 0.058 in catheter + 0.035 in guidewire (E 47 and 43 MPa); 10 patient CTAs",
   "trained": "policy (hierarchical modular multi-agent SAC, HM-MARL)",
   "observation": "3 guidewire tip points in 2D from overhead 4K camera + tracker; no vessel image",
   "action_space": "continuous rotation and translation speed, two devices",
   "gap_closing": "mesh rotation +/-10 deg and scale 0.7-1.3; tensile-tested stiffness; friction tuned iteratively; 0.5 s pause per step on the bench",
   "real_setup": "3D-printed transparent phantom (Clear V4) in glycerine; 10 bench episodes per task",
   "sim_success": "A1,2 right 100%; A2,3 right 100%; A1,2 left 100%; A2,3 left 94% (50 episodes)",
   "real_success": "100%, 70% (80% with 10-anatomy agent), 0%, 0%",
   "gap_measure": "right side -0/-30 points; left side -100 and -94 points; time 40.1 s -> 249 s and 22.3 s -> 421 s (p < 0.001); expert by hand 10/10 right, 2/10 left; authors: left failure \"potentially due to differences in friction and device properties\"",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "Strongest evidence that gap is task-dependent. Second crop robertshaw2026_towardb_frames.png = bench frames with simulated centreline at left."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "tian2026_visionlanguage",
   "year": 2026,
   "venue": "arXiv:2606.30698 (accepted IROS 2026)",
   "title": "Vision-Language Procedural Reasoning for Context-Aware Reward Modeling of Robotic Endovascular Guidewire Navigation",
   "doi": null,
   "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30698",
   "robot_id": "allvas_aopeng2021",
   "robot_used": "commercial ALLVAS dual-arm robot, gripper with grasp/release + rotate (Fig. 3)",
   "simulator": "SOFA digital twin of each phantom",
   "trained": "policy (SAC) trained with reward weights set by a fine-tuned Qwen2.5-VL-3B stage classifier; the VLM is absent at test time",
   "observation": "policy: local vessel geometry + tip pose; hardware: overhead camera, YOLOv5 tip detection, U-Net mask",
   "action_space": "continuous translation and rotation",
   "gap_closing": "stage-conditioned reward shaping; simulated X-ray-like appearance for the camera pipeline",
   "real_setup": "three anthropomorphic phantoms (coronary, carotid, renal) with pump flow, 30 trials per method and scenario",
   "sim_success": "N.R.",
   "real_success": "100%, 97%, 100% with VLM-shaped reward; SAC alone 70%, 73%, 73%; expert manual 93%, 97%, 100%",
   "gap_measure": "not measurable (no sim success); the gain is between rewards, not between domains",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full",
   "notes": "The language model outputs no robot command."
  },
  {
   "schema_version": 1,
   "key": "wang2026_rightheart",
   "year": 2026,
   "venue": "IEEE Robotics & Automation Magazine (Mar 2026)",
   "title": "From Patient-Specific Digital Twin to Real-World Phantom: Autonomous Right Heart Catheterization",
   "doi": "10.1109/MRA.2025.3642745",
   "url": null,
   "robot_id": null,
   "robot_used": "custom 2-DoF Swan-Ganz catheter robot: active-passive roller set with soft silicone layers (translation) + rotation stage with slip ring (continuous rotation); Aurora EM balloon calibration; RealSense camera",
   "simulator": "SOFA + BeamAdapter patient-specific digital twin (phantom E 10 kPa, nu 0.49, density 1.2 g/cm3, Rayleigh damping 0.1/0.1); Swan-Ganz catheter beam model",
   "trained": "policy by supervised learning (CNN decision model, behaviour cloning of user key-press controller; 150 virtual trials, 50 per phantom)",
   "observation": "balloon-catheter image (camera, segmentation-based 3D balloon tracking; Aurora as ground truth: within 3 mm, 3.6 ms per frame)",
   "action_space": "discrete: translate 5 mm, rotate left or right 20 deg, stop",
   "gap_closing": "patient-specific digital twin with calibrated material; twin vs real interaction compared in Fig. 2(b); deviations under 5 mm called non-critical",
   "real_setup": "three water-filled patient-specific right-heart phantoms, static and pulsatile heartbeat, 50 autonomous interventions per phantom, 10 expert operations per heartbeat rate",
   "sim_success": "N.R. (twin used to generate data, no sim success rate)",
   "real_success": ">= 96% static, >= 94% dynamic; trajectory consistency >= 34.63% better than expert",
   "gap_measure": "twin-vs-real interaction compared qualitatively (Fig. 2b) and by deviation (<5 mm criterion); no matched sim-vs-real success pair",
   "code_public": "no",
   "read_level": "full (text; table 1 is an image, not read)",
   "notes": "Missed by S7b. Cardiac, imitation-style transfer from digital twin, not RL. Roller drive with silicone layers is the one drive element named in a twin paper, but the twin imposes motion directly. Paper lists Karstensen 2022, Mei, Scarponi 2024, Robertshaw IRL, CathSim as related sim-to-real work."
  }
 ]
}
